OWNED

Owned

SWOT Analysis &
Strategic Insights

Strengths

S1

Lower prices than many competing brands

e.l.f. Beauty’s pricing gives shoppers a concrete reason to choose it over competitors. The average U.S. price of an e.l.f. Cosmetics product is about $7, compared with $10 for other leading mass-market brands and $30 for luxury brands. That price gap makes it easier for shoppers to try a new shade or follow a trend without spending much, giving e.l.f. a way to attract customers who might otherwise skip the purchase. It also reinforces the brand’s reputation for making beauty accessible and gives shoppers a reason to keep choosing e.l.f. when their budgets tighten.

S2

Strong popularity among younger consumers

e.l.f. Beauty’s strong teen following gives it an audience that may be more willing to try new products because they already like the brand. In a 2025 survey of 10,969 teens, e.l.f. ranked first among cosmetics brands with 36% preference, compared with 8% for Rare Beauty and 6% for Maybelline. That lead gives e.l.f. a larger base of young shoppers who may be willing to try a new launch and recommend it to friends. As those shoppers build their beauty routines, early familiarity can also help e.l.f. earn repeat purchases and remain a go-to brand into adulthood.

S3

Customer feedback helps guide product ideas

e.l.f.’s customer feedback gives the company an advantage when deciding which products to launch: it can spot habits shoppers have already adopted and build products around them. The company collects insights through its website and Beauty Squad loyalty program, which gives it a direct line to repeat shoppers and helps it understand what keeps them coming back. Additionally, its collaboration with Bubble, a skincare brand, shows how a specific customer habit can shape a launch. After noticing customers mixing and layering products from the two brands, e.l.f. turned that routine into a collaboration. Building on what shoppers already do gives e.l.f. a clearer basis for product decisions and gives customers a familiar reason to try something new.

Weaknesses

W1

Dependence on a few large retail customers

In fiscal 2026, just four stores, Target, Walmart, Amazon and Sephora, made up 52% of e.l.f. Beauty’s sales, with most of the Sephora sales coming from rhode, the skincare brand it bought in 2025. Relying on so few stores is risky, because much of e.l.f. Beauty’s appeal comes from products that are affordable and easy to find. If one of these stores cuts its shelf space or makes a new product harder to find online, shoppers may simply pick up a similar product from a competitor instead. The damage can also last longer than one lost sale: a shopper who likes the other brand may keep buying it, which makes it harder for e.l.f. Beauty to turn new shoppers into loyal customers.

W2

Business expenses growing faster than sales

e.l.f.’s expenses are rising faster than its sales, making growth more costly and putting pressure on profits. In fiscal 2026, selling, general and administrative expenses increased approximately 32%, compared with 25% sales growth. In the following quarter, those expenses rose 43% to $280.3 million, while sales increased 36%. Higher spending on marketing, merchandising, distribution and compensation means the company needs more money to support its expanding business. If this pattern continues, e.l.f. could report strong sales growth while keeping less of what it earns, leaving less room for new products or unexpected costs.

W3

Manufacturing concentrated in China

Sourcing and manufacturing most of its products in China leaves e.l.f. heavily dependent on one country to keep its business running. Although the company does work with separate manufacturers in other locations, a disruption in China could affect a very large share of its products at once. Production delays or shipping problems could leave popular items out of stock, interrupt launches and push shoppers toward competing brands. Finding replacement suppliers could also take time and increase costs, putting pressure on the affordable prices that help e.l.f. attract customers.

Opportunities

O1

Shoppers seeking affordable products that work well

Beauty shoppers are looking for products that deliver good results without costing too much. As they rethink expensive purchases, they may be more willing to try affordable alternatives. This creates an opportunity to reach shoppers who are switching from higher-priced products or looking to spend less on their beauty routines. A lower price can make trying an unfamiliar product feel like less of a financial risk. If that product meets their expectations, an initial switch could turn into repeat purchases, giving e.l.f a chance to gain lasting customers.

O2

Interest in makeup with skincare benefits

Makeup that combines color with skincare benefits is expected to help drive growth in the beauty market. Mass-market makeup sales increased 5% in the first half of 2026, with blush and makeup combination products among the categories driving that growth. This allows e.l.f. to reach shoppers interested in makeup formulas that offer more than color alone. Added skincare benefits can give consumers another reason to try a product and may make it feel more worthwhile to buy. Although combination makeup products are not always skincare hybrids, both of these trends create room for products that bring multiple benefits into one beauty routine.

O3

Interest in beauty connected to confidence and self-expression

Consumers are turning to beauty for confidence, self-expression and self-care, creating demand for experiences that help them feel good and look good. Mental well-being is especially important to Gen Z, while broader wellness interests are shaping everyday beauty routines. Interest in emotional experiences and greater acceptance of imperfection also creates room for beauty messages that feel more relatable. Together, these shifts offer a way to connect with shoppers who see beauty as a way to express themselves and enjoy their routines without the pressure to look perfect. This gives the category a role beyond appearance, making personal meaning another reason consumers may choose a product.

Threats

T1

Changing tariffs and trade rules

Government changes to tariffs and trade rules can suddenly increase the cost of bringing beauty products into the U.S. Tariff rates on Chinese imports ranged from 25% to as high as 170% during 2025, showing how quickly these costs can change. For e.l.f., unexpected increases could make affordable prices harder to maintain and push shoppers toward cheaper alternatives. Although the company later received approximately $51.1 million in tariff refunds, future government decisions could bring new costs. This uncertainty makes it harder to set prices and plan ahead, even when customer demand remains strong.

T2

Growth of affordable, ingredient-focused competitors

The growth of competitors offering affordable prices, appealing ingredients and new formulas gives shoppers more alternatives to e.l.f. Global Korean beauty sales increased 53% year over year, showing the growing popularity of these products. As more brands offer both value and skincare benefits, shoppers have fewer reasons to choose e.l.f. based on price alone. They may spend their beauty budgets across more brands or switch when another product catches their attention. This competition could make it harder for e.l.f. to attract new customers and keep existing shoppers coming back.

T3

Consumers buying fewer makeup products

Declining makeup purchases could make it harder for e.l.f. to grow sales. In the first half of 2026, U.S. mass-market makeup sales rose 5% in dollars, but the number of products sold fell. Makeup also grew more slowly than the overall mass beauty market, where sales increased 7%. Brands are competing for fewer makeup purchases, making it harder to sell additional products and attract repeat business. Although blush and other trend-driven products showed growth, that strength did not prevent unit sales from declining across mass-market makeup overall. For e.l.f., fewer items being purchased could limit growth even when shoppers remain interested in affordable beauty.

Strategic Insights

01

Build a makeup routine finder that matches shoppers’ needs to their budgets

Rationale

When young shoppers buy fewer makeup products, e.l.f. has to earn a place in the routine they’re building now. Being a teen favorite gives e.l.f. a head start, but starting college or work can change how much time shoppers have to get ready, what they want to spend, and what look they prefer (S2, O1, T3). Use Beauty Squad feedback to learn what shoppers ages 18–24 need from those new routines (S3). Then build a tool on e.l.f.’s website that lets shoppers enter their occasion, budget, desired number of products, skin concerns, and preferred finish (O3). The tool would recommend products within their budget, explain why each one fits, and let them buy individual items or the full routine. That gives shoppers a reason to choose e.l.f. even if they’re only buying one product.

Success metrics

Within six months, test the routine finder with 300 shoppers ages 18–24. Aim for 80% of surveyed users to say the recommendations fit their occasion, budget, and preferred look. Aim for 20% of shoppers who receive a list to add at least one recommended product to their cart. To see whether the tool helps sales, aim for a 10% higher purchase rate with shoppers offered the tool than with a group browsing the same products without it.

02

Show which retailers have a shopper’s exact shade in stock

Rationale

A shopper can want to choose an e.l.f. Beauty product, but end up buying from a competitor if they cannot find the exact shade they want. With four retailers accounting for 52% of e.l.f. Beauty’s sales, helping shoppers find that shade elsewhere can keep one store’s limited availability from costing the brand a sale (W1, T2). A general store locator may send shoppers to a retailer that carries the product but does not have the exact shade they want. An exact shade finder would show which participating sellers have that specific shade in stock. If none have it, shoppers could sign up for a restock alert. This makes e.l.f.’s affordable products easier to buy at the moment shoppers are ready to purchase (S1, O1)..

Success metrics

Within six months, test 20 popular shades with at least two retail partners. Aim for 20% of shoppers who encounter an out-of-stock shade to click through to a seller with that exact shade or sign up for a restock alert. Track the two actions separately.

03

Add easy-to-read messages to product pages that explain stock delays and price increases

Rationale

When a favorite product is delayed or gets more expensive, e.l.f. can protect its reputation for value by helping shoppers decide what to do next (S1). Manufacturing disruptions can affect availability (W3), and changing tariffs can put pressure on prices (T1). Add a pink icon beside the stock status or price on the affected product page, with a tappable label such as “Where’s my shade?” or “Why did the price change?” Tapping it would open a short note explaining what happened and what shoppers can do next. Answering the question where shoppers are deciding what to buy gives them a practical choice: wait for the product they want or try a similar e.l.f. option within their budget when one is available.

Success metrics

Within six months, test the icon on up to five product pages affected by a stock delay or price change. Aim for 20% of visitors who see the icon to tap it and 80% of surveyed shoppers who open the note to correctly explain what changed and what they can do next. When the note offers a similar product within budget, aim for 15% of shoppers who see the note to click through.

adminalexisli_3lo2142nEdit Profile